Common Misconceptions about Restorative Justice

Posted on: 18th, October 2024

Restorative Justice can be an incredibly powerful process to take part in for victims and offenders, but there are, unfortunately, many misconceptions about the practice. If you’re considering taking part, making sure you’re fully informed can help ease your mind and help you decide whether it’s the right approach for you. 

Restorative Justice is the ‘soft’ option

Restorative Justice seeks to help victims take back a sense of control and gain a sense of closure from the experience, as well as help offenders see the effects of their actions and put the crime behind them. The process seeks to hold the offender accountable in a way that is meaningful to the victim and it does not result in a lighter sentence for the offender as Restorative Justice takes place after a sentence has been given. 

Restorative Justice is only appropriate for “minor” offences 

No crimes are off limits for Restorative Justice and it can be used for any type of crime as long as both parties (the victim and offender) agree to take part. Restorative Justice can be a beneficial process for small offences and even the most serious of crimes, such as murder and abuse, and anything in between. 

Each case is handled on an individual basis with specially-trained facilitators working with the victim and offender to make the process safe and secure to achieve the best possible outcome. 

Restorative Justice requires forgiveness

There have been many cases where the offender apologises and the victim expresses forgiveness which is fantastic, but this is not required or expected. The purpose of Restorative Justice is to bring the victim and offender into open communication in a safe, facilitated environment. 

Giving the victim the chance to ask questions about the crime and letting the offender see the victim as a real person and the real impact of their crime. Not only does this help reduce symptoms of anxiety, stress, depression and PTSD for the victim, but taking part in Restorative Justice can also reduce reoffending rates by 27% (Sherman/Strang 2007). 

Restorative Justice has to take place face to face 

If it is established that a face to face meeting is not the right approach for the victim and offender, indirect Restorative Justice can be done. This can be facilitated through phone calls, video calls, letter writing, emails or passing on messages through a third party. 

If you have been affected by a crime and think Restorative Justice is the right step for you, be sure to get in touch with us. 

Talk to our Restorative Justice service team in confidence

Email Us

Or call us on 0800 783 1550

Case Studies

A burglary case in West Yorkshire

John burgled Lucy’s home when she was outside hanging out her washing. When she came inside, she found him standing in her property. She describe...

Read More

A Domestic Argument

Ann and her son, Nicky, had been enjoying an evening in together.  As the evening progressed, an argument started, which then escalated. ...

Watch Here

A Non-Recent Child Sexual Abuse Case

A complaint of historical sexual abuse was reported to the police by two sisters who accused their stepfather of sexually touching them when they w...

Read More

A Serious Assault Case

Caroline’s world was turned upside down when Simon, her partner, was punched in the face and knocked to the ground as he walked home from a night...

Read More

A Sexual Abuse Case

The Restorative Justice service received a referral from Sarah, via her Victim Liaison Officer. The offences, which were of a sexual nature, were c...

Read More

A Street Robbery

Daniel contacted the Restorative Justice team after he committed a street robbery on Carl. “The p...

Read More

A Traffic Offence Case

Anne, 65, contacted the service, as she was interested in Restorative Justice. Her husband, Brian, 63, had been killed in a traffic collision 18 mo...

Read More

Assault on a Police Officer in West Yorkshire

Coleen was a West Yorkshire Police Officer who was called to a report of sexual assault. Upon arrival at the address, there were a lot of people, m...

Watch Here

Conditional Cautions and Restorative Justice

One evening in December 2023, Brad was driving along a motorway when a car indicated to join the carriageway from a slip road, causing him to swerv...

Read More

Death By Dangerous Driving

The Restorative Justice service received an enquiry from a Victim Liaison Officer from the National Probation Service detailing that there w...

Watch Here

Death by Dangerous Driving: Tara & Oliver

Tara was referred to the Restorative Justice team in West Yorkshire. Her brother, Thomas, had been killed three years previously by Oliver, who had...

Read More

Hate Crime Awareness Course

Amiya was allocated as the Case Manager for Warren. Warren had a history of racial and religiously aggravated harassment towards a variety of peopl...

Watch Here

Lydia's Story: Sexual Assault

Lydia was referred to the Restorative Justice service by her Victim Liaison Officer. She was the victim of a prolonged sexual assault at her home 1...

Read More

Restorative Justice With A Prolific Offender

SR was a prolific offender and addicted to heroin when he burgled KM twice (once on 18th September 2023 and again on 26th September 2023) in order ...

Read More

Street Robbery

Ellis was a long term substance user, who was encouraged by an acquaintance – Mikel - to grab the handbag of a woman they saw in passing.  A...

Read More

Street Robbery

Jemma was referred to Restorative Solutions by Victim Services in July 2019.  She had been the victim of a robbery.  The offender – Ale...

Read More

Using a Restorative Approach to Address Conflict in the Home

A son was displaying an increasing level of verbal and physical abuse within the home. Mum has reached the point that she was scared that she could...

Read More
Next
Previous
What People Say About Restorative Justice

The restorative justice process has made me really think about the consequences of my actions.

John, offender

Restorative Justice has really helped. It has given me closure, and I feel much more positive.

Lucy, burglary victim

Now we can get on with our lives without the burden of what happened grinding us down.

Abuse victim

Next
Previous
Our Partners